May 04, 2007
The Great Debate
I didn't get invited to the Republican Presidential Candidate's Debate. It may be because I'm not a Republican and I'm not a candidate. But whatever. They left me off the guest list, and it's just not right.
Luckily, I found a transcript of the questions, so even though I wasn't on the stage I can still get my answers into the record. Keep in mind I don't have a staff of handlers to coach me on proper sound bites, and there have been no rehearsals.
In the NBC-Wall Street Journal poll, just 22 percent believe this country is on the right track. Mayor Giuliani, how do we get back to Ronald Reagan's "morning in America"?
I am not now nor have I ever been Mayor Giuliani. Next question.Most of the public pessimism today has to do with Iraq. How -- what would you need, as commander in chief, to win the war in Iraq?
I would need a team of people who were charged with making sure the whole story of Iraq is told to the American people. The people know only half of the story - since the death toll - particularly of US military personnel is about the only story they ever hear.Recent polls in the Islamic world reveal a sea of hostility toward the United States, feeding what General Petraeus calls the central front of al Qaeda in Iraq. How do we win this war if every dead terrorist is so easily replaced?
I find most domestic public opinion polls silly and irrelevant, why would I care about those?How do you deal with the problem, revealed in a recent Zogby poll, that in countries that are moderate, you mentioned -- like Jordan, Morocco, Turkey, another Islamic country -- 10, 12 percent of the people support us; the rest are angry at us. Doesn't that create a sea of recruitment opportunity for our enemy? And how -- I'm just asking, do we have to reduce that temperature of hatred before we win the war, or simply continue to fight the terrorists?
Didn't I just get through telling you what I think about polls?I'd like to get your views about how you balance loyalty and accountability. Would you have fired Don Rumsfeld before last November?
Loyalty is immensely important to me. But loyalty without accountability is not loyalty it's blind faith. No one gets that.Do you think a general shake-up in this administration's Cabinet right now would be good for the administration?
I think it would give the press something to jabber about for a while. Certainly the Senate confirmation process would give the Democrat's greater opportunity to control the White House from the Capital building. I don't think it would do much for the president though.Former Tennessee Senator Fred Thompson said that Iran has already committed acts of war. Do you agree? And secondly, as part of that, what's your trip wire for a U.S. strike in Iran?
Yes. fred is right. The only thing we lack is a Congress with the backbone to support doing anything about it.Imagine you're president of the United States and this is a likely or possible scenario, certainly plausible. You get a call from the prime minister of Israel, the prime minister of Israel, who's now Ehud Olmert, saying Israel's about to strike Iran's nuclear sites and he wants U.S. help. What do you say?
What do you need and when do you need it?When speaking about Osama bin Laden last week, Governor Romney said, quote, "It's not worth moving heaven and earth, spending billions of dollars, just trying to catch one person." Senator McCain called that naive. Who's right?
The governor is the closest to being right. We need to continue efforts to deal with bin Laden as an individual. But the hunt for one man cannot overshadow the war against Islamic Extremists.Sarah (sp) from Arlington, Virginia, wants to know if you would comfortable with Tom Tancredo, a staunch opponent of illegal immigration, as head of the Immigration and Naturalization Service.
Certanly, but I think he may have other career aspirations at the moment.Should we change our Constitution which we believe is divinely inspired -- -- to allow men like Mel Martinez, the chairman of your party, born in Cuba, great patriot, senator from Florida, and Arnold Schwarzenegger to stand here some night?
I neither believe the Constitution was divinely inspired nor do think this would be an appropriate amendment.Daniel Dukovnic (sp) from Walnut Creek, California, wants to know: What do you dislike most about America?
People who refuse to see anything good in America.Do you believe global warming exists?
Do I believe that the climatic temperature of the planet is not a fixed number and that at some times it is generally warmer or cooler than others yes.David Diamond from Memphis writes in, "Do you have a plan to solve the shortage of organs donated for transplant?"
No. Other than speaking to the issue and encouraging people to sign donor cards, this is not a problem the President or the government should be involved in.Maggie from Highland Park, Illinois, wants to know if you consider yourself a compassionate conservative, like President Bush.
No.If you were president, would you work to phase out the IRS?
Phasing it out sounds like it would take too long. Can't we just give them two weeks notice?Would the day that Roe v. Wade is repealed be a good day for Americans?
Yes. Because it is a poorly set precedent that represents a Federal usurpation of state authority.Would you support the use of public funds for abortion? [edited]
No. The crux of the Roe v. Wade decision is that this a private issue between the patient and the doctor. If the procedure is a private matter, the bill should be too.We're in the house of Ronald Reagan. Every cab driver in America knew what Ronald Reagan stood for: defeat communism abroad, reduce big government at home. Can you restore that kind of unity of purpose?
Yes. Except there's not much left of the communism that Reagan was fighting. I would have to substitute terrorists for the Russians (like they did in the movies before it was politically incorrect.)How do you unify the country the way Reagan did, a good portion of the country?
Present a clear an consistent vision of the great nation that we live in. Keep that vision in front of the people.How do you reconcile this moral -- moral leadership kind of role of conservatism with the very libertarian strain of conservatism, the Barry Goldwater conservatism that you represent? How do you put together what he just said with what you believe in a unified national purpose?
Lead people toward freedom, individual responsibility and self reliance. I would consider that moral leadership.What do you say to Roman Catholic bishops who would deny communion to elected officials who support abortion rights?
Nothing. It's their church they can do what they want free from interference from the government. Read the First Amendment.Congressman Hunter, Governor Schwarzenegger -- who is here tonight -- has won the state twice by downplaying partisanship and taking centrist positions on the environment, immigration, abortion. Is that the way to win for Republicans?
Well, my name's not Hunter but I'll take this one anyway. I don't believe in taking any position just because I think it might help me win. I believe in standing on principles and the strength of my ideas. If the people agree with those ideas they will vote for me.Do you want to keep [Karl Rove] in the White House if you get elected president as the president's chief political operative?
Why? I've got my own people. But then again it would annoy some people who are worth annoying.Has the increased influence of Christian conservatives in your party been good for it?
Has the decreased influence of any and all faith been good for yours? Besides this is not my party - I'm just crashing here.What's with your party and all this corruption?
I think we would be far better served by just focusing on eliminating all corruption rather than having a contest to see which party has the most scandals. I think there is plenty of corruption on both sides of the aisle and we need to deal with all of it.A through F, how would you rate the Bush administration's handling of the Iraq war?
Overall a C+ though with the early progress of the new security strategy I might bump that to a B-.Is racism still a problem in our society? And can a president do anything about it?
I believe there are still many areas where race is an issue in this country. I believe the President can do a lot to lead the nation toward realising the dream of Martin Luther King. That we all be judged by the content of our character and not the color of our skin.David Kim (sp) from here in California wants to know, beside yourself, who do you think should be the Republican nominee for president of the United States, and why?
With no offense to the esteemed gentlemen on the stage, no one. If I didn't believe that I was the best person for the job I wouldn't be here.Anyone with disagree with the strong anti-illegal immigration position?
Not me.Kenyu Thomas (sp) from Honolulu, Hawaii, wants to know if you watched Al Gore's environmental documentary, "An Inconvenient Truth."
No. Nor do I plan to.Bob Hussey (sp) from Minnesota writes that perhaps the most important skill a good president must have is the ability to make good, sound decisions, often in a crisis situation. Please cite an example when you had to make a decision in crisis.
I always try to make decisions before we get to the point of crisis. Helps to keep the stress levels manageable.This question comes from Malika (sp) in Washington, DC. Women are the fastest growing prison population. Most are mothers who are non-violent, first-time offenders. What will you do to address the issue of mothers behind bars and the children left behind?
I believe the advice Jim Carey gave to a client in the movie Liar Liar sums it up best: "Stop breaking the law a$$hole."We have Mrs. Reagan here. The camera will not focus on her, but I will tell you, it will now focus on you. Mrs. Reagan wants to expand federal funding of embryonic stem cell research. Will that progress under your administration?
I would do everything in my power to make sure the federal government stays out of the way.I want each candidate to mention a tax he'd like to cut, in addition to the Bush tax cuts, keeping them in effect.
Death tax, Marriage tax, Capital Gains Tax, if it's a tax I'm interested in cutting it.Senator McCain, you said you plan to appoint a Democrat to a major Cabinet post. Tell us some of the Democrats you've got in mind. We'll give you bonus points if you give us a name other than Senator Lieberman.
Sorry you must be confused. I am actually a believer in free and unfettered speech - especially in the political process. Do. Not. Ever. Call. Me. McCain. Again.Ryan from Los Angeles wants you to name one thing that the federal government does really well and one thing that it does poorly.
The Federal government spends money very well. What it does poorly is spend it wisely.Do you believe in evolution?
Yes.Robert Dietricht (sp) from Towson, Maryland, wants to know which Cabinet official would be at the top of the list of those you'd like to carry into your administration if you're elected.
I would probably bring in my own posse.He wants to know, what is the difference between a Sunni and a Shi'a Muslim?
I suggest he open a book or look it up on Google.Carrie (sp) from Connecticut asks, do you trust the mainstream media?
I think you can always trust the mainstream media to by and large present a consistently left leaning narrative. I think they can be trusted to downplay or ignore any American success particularly if conservatives hold leadership.A reader wants to know if your personal religious beliefs influence your foreign policy thinking.
The reader is an idiot. If a person professes to religious beliefs then tells you that their beliefs will not effect their thinking, that person is a liar - either about their faith or their thinking.Jessie (sp) from Madison wants to know, what do you consider to be your most significant weakness as a candidate for the president of the United States?
I don't have any money. I'm not part of a party. No one knows who I am. Should I go on?In light of the scandals plaguing the current administration and its allies, involving corruption and cronyism, which mistakes have you learned not to repeat?
I think we need to create as much openness in the government as possible so we shine a bright light on the corrupt cockroaches that infest our government. It might be hard when it's a Senator steering military contracts to a company owned by a spouse or who's collecting bribes connected to military contracts because there can be classified information involved. But when such things are exposed those responsible should be subject to the full force of the law.Will you work to protect women's rights, as in fair wages and reproductive choice?
I will protect the rights of very individual. That's part of the job. I will protect the rights of the employee and the employer to pay and receive a fair wage that they agree to. I fully support a woman's right to choose to reproduce - as long as she is willing to accept the responsibility for her reproduction.I want you to explain it and defend it: a national tamper-proof ID card.
A handy way to control the movement of the population and keep tabs on people. As for defending it, I can't defend the indefensible.Do you think Scooter Libby should be pardoned?
If Skooter broke the law he doesn't deserve a pardon. Come to think of it a grown man who goes by the name Skooter shouldn't get a pardon anyway.Let me ask you a question which has grabbed a lot of Americans personally, the Terri Schaivo case. Again, it was a question of whether the United States -- the U.S. Congress should have intervened and passed a law to advise the appellate court whether to act or not in this case, the district court it was. Terri Schaivo, should Congress have acted or let the family make the decision, the husband?
The idea of the federal government attempting to decide individual court cases legislatively is an appalling overreach of authority and I find it abhorrent.Seriously, would it be good for America to have Bill Clinton back living in the White House?
Since the only way that will happen is if Hillary Clinton is elected president I can't think of a worse thing for America.How will you be different in any way from President George W. Bush?
I will not forget domestic issues such as reigning in the federal government in size and authority while resolutely fighting the war against Islamic terrorists. I may have a tendency to swagger, but I don't have a Texas drawl.I should have been there. I would have mopped the floor with those guys.
Posted by: Stephen Macklin at 01:23 PM | Comments (1) | Add Comment
1
Great answers, Senator McCai-- er... Citizen Macklin!
Posted by: Tuning Spork at May 05, 2007 03:51 PM (HssZH)
37kb generated in 0.0401 seconds; 40 queries returned 178 records.
Powered by Minx 1.1.4-pink.
Powered by Minx 1.1.4-pink.









