November 02, 2005

This Shouldn't Be Necessary

UPDATED

John Hinderaker at Powerline posts to let us know that


Later today, the House of Representatives will vote on the Online Freedom of Speech Act, which is expected to pass easily.


Gee thanks guys but if you hadn't passed the horrific Bipartisan Campaign Finance Reform Act, AKA McCain/Fiengold, this wouldn't be necessary at all now would it.


If we had a President who kept to his promise and vetoed this piece dreck in the first place, this legislation wouldn't be necessary. (But then again I'm not so sure he's even vetoed pretzels as a presidential snack food.)


If we had more justices sitting on the Supreme Court who could look at congress making a law that abridges freedom of speech and think "Hmm. Maybe this is contrary to the rather plain language of the Constitution that says 'Congress shall make no law abridging freedom of speech'" this legislation wouldn't be necessary.


I appreciate the efforts of those who are pushing this legislation but if you guys hadn't all gotten together and screwed it all up in the first place this wouldn't be necessary. So forgive me if not all that ready to give you a pat on the back for fixing something you never should have broken in the first place.


We already have an "Online Freedom of Speech Act." We more commonly refer to it as the First Amendment.


UPDATE: Apparently, the members of the House of Representatives think so little of citizens right to free speech they couldn't even bring themselves to pass an unnecessary and redundant piece of legislation aimed at undoing the greater harm they already done.

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Posted by: Stephen Macklin at 01:41 PM | Comments (2) | Add Comment


1 Stephen- I appreciated your comments on this topic here and on Reason Hit & Run. I especially value your comment about how a protection was unnecessary because we have something called the First Amendment.

Alas, and whither commom sense, and all that.

Posted by: Mike Kole at November 03, 2005 06:51 PM (Oo0Ze)

2 Let's keep hammering away at this. In Oregon 4 out of 5 voted against this bill and we hope to make them accountable!
Mover Mike

Posted by: Mike Landfair at November 04, 2005 09:19 AM (rc+Fc)

Hide Comments | Add Comment






23kb generated in 0.0386 seconds; 40 queries returned 179 records.
Powered by Minx 1.1.4-pink.